How did gimli not know about moria. Elthir Cat in a Coat.

How did gimli not know about moria Lord of the Rings: Why Didn't Gimli Know About the Dwarves' Fate in Moria?,The Dwarves' fate in Moria was a tragedy in The Lord of the Rings universe, so why didn't Gimli know about it when he arrived with the Fellowship? How did Gimli not know Moria was a graveyard? Movies How long had communication from Moria stopped at that point? I thought it was common knowledge they were all toast at that time in the books. My assumption is 'not all the dwarves thought it was a good idea. Gimli and his father Gloin, who were both at the Council of Elrond, were not nearly as optimistic in finding Balin alive in Moria, as the movie-Gimli was. He only discovered it once the Fellowship of the Ring arrived in the mines, and he saw Balin's tomb. 'Deep is the abyss that is spanned by Durin's Bridge, and none has measured it,' said Gimli. ' Today we take a look at the confusing subject of just why Gimli was not aware of the outcome of Balin's expedition into Moria, despite it being many years si They did not die 500 years before. . Member. While debating their next move, they were attacked by a pack of Wargs. Maybe mistake?) He won from such a huge gap in points too. We know (or at least suspect, I don't have the books with me) that Orcs entered Moria from Dol Guldur, and they would be under Sauron's command. Sooo: A. A. Gimli is much more certain of Balin's success in the movies than he is in de book. He later How Come Didn't Gimli Know About the Dwarves' Fate in Moria in LOTR? This theory explains why Gimli, son of Glóin, didn't know anything about Moria's final fate in The Fellowship of the Ring. Elthir Cat in a Coat. November 3rd, 2023, 06:44 PM . C. Gandalf knew about Barlog deep dawn but not about the fall. This culminated in the final battle outside of the eastern gate of Moria. Óin is killed by the Watcher in the Water, Balin is shot by an orc, and Ori dies in Balin's Tomb, his corpse featuring briefly in The Fellowship of the Ring. I can see why you don't like it, especially when characters use it in front of Gimli. **It's like Ask Science, but all questions and answers are written with Gandalf didn’t know for sure if Moria was lost or not, he also didn’t know about the Balrog. Gimli didn't know about Moria's fate because there had been no communication between Erebor and Moria for 25 years, and the Dwarves were hopeful and did not want to accept failure until there was ‘That was nigh on thirty years ago. 'What happened away up there at the door?' he asked. Gimli is skeptical before he ever sets foot in Moria, and when they arrive at the 'habitable' parts of Eastern Moria, Gimli gives voice to his doubts, saying "We have still seen I recently rewatched first movie and this one struck me. It seems like its pretty common knowledge in Middle-Earth that the Dwarves ended up unleashing a Balrog by digging to deep After a decade of relative quietness compared to the previous one, without a doubt, Lord of the Rings is experiencing somewhat of a resurgence. Lord of the Rings: Why Didn't Gimli Know About the Dwarves' Fate in Moria?,The Dwarves' fate in Moria was a tragedy in The Lord of the Rings universe, so why didn't Gimli know about it when he arrived with the Fellowship? Gimli did know that Moria is a dangerous place, but he didn’t know that his cousin Balin’s expedition has failed so horribly. Gimli also does show enthusiasm to enter Moria in the book and I'm guessing that's because he's being an optimist here. I did not like throwing away or tossing aside what All trace of Gollum is lost. ‘He may watch all roads, likely and unlikely. Yet, somehow, Gimli However, it's strange Gimli wasn't aware of Balin's, and Moria's, grim fate. The Dwarves know that Moria was abandoned because of the Balrog, who is called Durin's Bane by them because he killed their king Durin VI, and the Dwarves had to flee Moria. 'I said not so; yet evil came,' answered Legolas sadly. Balin’s expedition went to Moria about 30 years before Gimli and the rest of the Fellowship, and there were no words about their destiny. Gimli was a distant relative of King Durin VI, Yet Fangorn holds some secret of its own. How come Gimli and his folk didn't know? Didn't they wonder why the Posted by u/MrCance - 103 votes and 83 comments The Doors of Durin were the western entrance to the Mines of Moria in J. Gimli and Gloin know all about Moria, what they don't know is the fate of one small expedition of intrepid or foolhardy dwarves that went back to Moria quite recently (about twenty years previously) to try and establish a small foothold. " The other characters do not speak about preferences. Controversial. 'And what has become of Balin and Ori and Óin?' asked Frodo. In the books In the book, Gandalf does not know that there's a Balrog in Moria; he knew after the Chamber of Mazarbul that there was something quite powerful there, but it was only at the Bridge that he became aware of what he faced: "a Balrog, now By the time of the quest, Gimli and the dwarves of Erebor had a pretty good idea that some disaster had befallen Balin and Co, but they did not know what happened. Same with the Uruk Hai at helms deep. Old. We don't know why PJ made this change. the Dwarves of Erebor obviously knew about the initial Balrog attack (they only went to Erebor in the first place as refugees from Moria). He has some good moments, but overall his role in the movies was greatly diminished and dumbed down compared to the books. It was Aragorn who feared going through Moria: `You speak of what you do not know, when you liken Moria to the stronghold of Sauron,' answered Gandalf. I did battle with the White Gems alot and I chose to stuck with it as I personally felt like keeping stuff that Peter Jackson did. Gimli wants to go there because it is his ancestral home and a really big deal for Durin's Folk. Wasn’t the lack of communication or arrogance? Don't insult the precious, my precious!:book: Find. How did Gimli not know about Moria? Gimli did know that Moria is a dangerous place, but he didn’t know that his cousin Balin’s expedition has failed so horribly. Joined Nov 28, 2004 Messages ETA: And Gandalf's words definitely imply that he did not know what it was until that moment. So Gimli (and Gandalf) suspected that Balin and his company may have died, but they didn't know for sure. In fact, one of the reasons that Gimli and Gloin go to Elrond is to ask for advice about Moria, in addition, to warning Bilbo that emissaries of Sauron have come to their land asking for In the books Gandalf tells Gloin and Gimli that had Balin come to him he would have warned him not to go to Moria. Early in that sequence we see Gandalf diving head first to catch up with the Balrog, so he was probably falling at the higher end of that range. It took about 15 years between Balin getting defeated in Moria en Gimli and the fellowship walking through Moria. But Gandalf’s How did Gimli not know that Moria had been taken over by orcs as well as the balrog in Fellowship of the Ring? upvotes Why did Gimli not know the password? 2 Answers. ’ Source - The Lord of the Rings, The Fellowship of the Ring, "A Journey in the Dark" Timeline Thra´in lost: TA 2841 Gandalf travel to Moria: Between TA 2841 - TA 2850 29 votes, 11 comments. 51 Replies. In the books one of the reason Gloin and Gimli went to Rivendell was to ask Elrond's advice regarding Balin's missing colonists. Does Orlando Bloom have tattoos? Gandalf did know he couldn't take the hobbits all the way into Mordor since as a Maia he would be sensed so he knew their paths would diverge at some point. This is correct, Gandalf also likely last passed through Moria before Balin’s expedition which, although the films don’t really show the scale of it, was a very large expedition to retake the mines and many Dwarves having seen the glory of Thorin and the company when retaking The Lone Mountain (a greatly more challenging task than a few orcs obviously 👀) followed Balin to Moria Gandalf doesn't know what, exactly, Durin's Bane might be, but both he and Gimli, and likely Aragorn and Legolas, and maybe even Frodo and Boromir, would know that the last time there was a major Dwarf kingdom in Moria, they delved too greedily and deep and something terrible drove them out. Even the dwarves don't know about the extent of the natural tunnels they pierced when they set free Durin's Bane, and they don't talk about the deepest levels where they dug for mithril, only that it was found "at the root of the mountain". Moria was first defeated by the orcs and Durin's Bane (the balrog) and then abandoned by the dwarves in Third Age 1989. What it is I do not know. ' Balin actually leads a party to Moria against the wishes of Dain, King under the Mountain. The Fellowship fled to Moria, rather than deliberately choosing that course of Therefore, it is possible that Gimli simply did not know Balin well enough to be aware of his fate in the Mines of Moria. All he knew was that Balin’s mission was initially successful, which is How Did Gimli Not Know About Moria? One would think that a disaster like that would be known among the Dwarves, especially considering it was a mission to retake a long-lost Dwarven kingdom. In the Fellowship Gimli has no idea Moria has been over run by orcs and goblins, hence the reason why he is horrified when he enters the mine with the fellowship. They also had a fair idea that Balin was unsuccessful Glóin sighed. 94 Likes. 35 votes, 19 comments. He did not say what he found there on his first visit, or when it was. Yet, somehow, Gimli How did Gimli not know that Moria had been taken over by orcs as well as the balrog in Fellowship of the Ring? In the movie it implied that Gimli thought Balin was alive and well in Moria, and it did not really explain at all that Moria had been abandoned a thousand years ago and only a small expedition sent back to retake it. `Moria! Moria! The path through Moria was almost the doom of the quest and everyone seemed to know that would be the case going in, except for Gandalf. Why didn’t Gimli know Moria had fallen? badlands Posting Freak. Balin and the others died not too long after that event, so they could have discovered the riddle and password and even written about it, but did not have the opportunity to pass along the information to anyone outside Moria and no one had gone inside and found the book until the Uncovering the Mystery of Gimli and Moria • Gimli's Moria Mystery • Discover why Gimli was surprised by the true state of Moria in 'The Lord of the Rings' an Gimli's down to go, but only because he's like "I must know what happened to Balin and if Moria can be saved". No, everyone assumes they died in the book. Then there was silence, and no word has ever come from Moria since. Aragorn says he does not wish to go, but he will. If not, perhaps the fall of Moria was the perspective/the object lesson Gimli needed in order to fulfill Galadriel’s prophecy: “() But if hope should not fail, then I say to you, Gimli son of Glóin, that your hands shall flow with gold, and yet over you gold shall have no dominion. It's been a minute since I read them, but in the books, when the Balrog reveals itself to the Fellowship, the only two who seem to know what they're looking at aside from Gandalf are Legolas and Gimli, if I recall correctly. CBR. Even to the hobbits it was a legend of vague fear Kenny Chung (@kennychungk). did Gandalf travel through Moria in the past before Balin’s group? I do not wish to enter Moria a second time. Ask away! The Mines of Moria is home to one of the most well-known scenes throughout the entire Lord of the Rings trilogy. 'Did you meet the beater of the drums?' 'I do not know,' answered Gandalf. Gimli not knowing about Balin’s death in the Mines of Moria can be attributed to a combination of factors, including his absence from the events, the secrecy of the Dwarves, and his own relationship with Balin. Moria was inhabited by orcs and a Balrog for a thousand years. Close. The Balrog rampaged in Moria for several years, slaying at least two kings. The journey to Moria was dangerous, so many messengers could Although Gimli knew that Moria could be dangerous in the book, he did not know about Balin’s death in The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring movie possibly due to slow communication and Dwarves’ perception of time. Gimli and the other Dwarves lived in In the books, Gimli and the dwarves lost contact with the dwarves of Moria years ago, and are already wondering what happened. Balin is his kin, and Gimli has an obligation here. ” However, he had no idea about the circumstances under which Balin’s expedition failed, as the exact details couldn’t be known Both Gimli and Gandalf know of Moria being a dangerous place, but they don't know Balin's mission has failed so catastrophically. For anyone else who doesn't know, Moria is Sindarin for "Black Chasm", while Khazad-dûm is Dwarvish for "Manson of Did Gandalf Know The Mines Of Moria Had Fallen? In The Lord of the Rings, Gimli had no idea the Mines of Moria had fallen, which is why he suggested taking the road through Moria. Maybe orcs, or a troll, if anything was even still there. Gimli isn't particularly hopeful when they enter Moria 'The road that I speak of leads to the Mines of Moria,' said Gandalf. Share Add a Comment. 854K subscribers in the AskScienceFiction community. Gimli knew Moria had fallen into shadow. How did Gimli know about the doors to Moria? Gimli was born in the Blue Mountains. Doesnt make a difference but its strange seeing such a small change. Why doesn't Gimli know what's happened to Moria, and why does Gandalf seem to skirt around telling them about the mine's fate? Share Add a Comment. OP. Jun 22, 2020 Why did Gimli not know about Moria? Gimli did know that Moria is a dangerous place, but he didn’t know that his cousin Balin’s expedition has failed so horribly. How on middle earth did Gimli not know about the Mines of Moria but two wizards halfway across the continent know everything about it including the summoning of a demon fire monster? Therefore, it is possible that Gimli simply did not know Balin well enough to be aware of his fate in the Mines of Moria. Now Gimli wants to go to Moria, but it is Gandalf who mentions that there is a possibility of Balin being there, not Gimli. 'But the Dwarves did not make the evil,' said Gimli. When Moria first comes up: Why did Gimli not know what happened in Moria? I’m re watching the trilogy starting with the fellowship of the ring. In the books, at least, the west gate of Moria had not been used for 1,037 to 4,763 years, making it unlikely that the password had been handed down to Gimli. Which Dwarves died in Moria? The Hobbit dwarves Óin, Balin and Ori all die prior to The Lord of the Rings, when a colony is sent from Erebor to reclaim the Mines of Moria. He can be poetic,but he is also very blunt. The remaining dwarvern host did not have the strength or will to enter Moria itself. ''Dark is the water of Kheled-zâram, and cold are the springs of Kibil-nâla, and fair were the many-pillared halls of Khazad-dûm in Elder Days before the fall of mighty kings beneath the stone. Therefore, they first went to This is why the dwarves did not return to Moria, and why Balin was a fool to have done so. Reply. It seems that the dwarves did not know what Durin's Bane was — Durin's folk had not been involved in the wars of the First Age and even if Most members of the Fellowship did not know what the Balrog was. ’ ‘And I do not wish to know,’ said Gimli. R. When the opposite turned out to be true, he was extremely distressed but not surprised. 1; 2; Gimli took his arm and helped him down to a seat on the step. Why didn’t Gimli know of the fall of Moria? As someone closely related to the king of Moria, how could he not have known of morias ruin? That question just came to me after rewatching the fellowship. The name of Moria is black. The book is a longer scene that would've looked silly in the movie ( too much empty, low action screen time) but the book scene really drives home this idea that Gandalf is trying too hard to find the answer. A shadow passed over Glóin's face. It brings his character down to Earth a bit. Talking about going to Moria: ‘The road that I speak of leads to the Mines of Moria,’ said Gandalf. Gimli eventually learned of their fate when he crossed the dwarven realm with the Company of the Ring and found Balin's Tomb. Gandalf's first encounter was the spell-duel at the door. I would say Gimli (overall) is a better fighter than Legolas, despite the way the movies portray things. In the Second Age of Middle-earth, Celebrimbor the Elf and Narvi the Dwarf worked In the film of the Two Towers we see Gandalf and the Balrog in free fall. So in the book, Gandalf and Gimli(he want to see/or learn about his kin) thinks Moria is a good choice, but Aragorn has a bad feeling about it. No one knew. [4] Gimli eventually learned of their fate when he crossed the dwarven realm with the Fellowship of the Ring. r/lotrmemes. He warns Thrain that the monster is still in Moria, but he doesn't offer a description or claim to have actually seen it. Gimli and Gandalf were the only ones in the books that wanted to go to Moria. the very being that had massacred the Dwarves of Moria long ago. [18] Gimli might not have known about the fall of Moria simply because Erebor had not grown too worried about the lack of information yet. Oct 25, 2017 40,317. A. Is Thorin a bad guy? How does Gimli not know of the fall of his own people, while Gandalf does? It was Aragorn who said he had been in Moria before and did not wish to repeat the experience. We're not sure exactly how that works - whether they just increase your luck at finding gold and whatnot, but it has to actually exist, or something else - but the Rings didn't One of the changes I didnt really like from the books, for sure. 'But I found myself suddenly faced by something I have not met before, I could think of nothing to do but to try and put a shutting-spell on the door. But Gandalf’s Making Gimli comedic relief (and kinda dumb) led to some problems like this. How did Gimli not know of the demise of Moria? upvotes · comments. What does Sam throw at Bill Ferny as they are leaving Bree? And you, Sammie, don’t go ill-treating my poor old pony!” (1. Moria was a 'The road that I speak of leads to the Mines of Moria,' said Gandalf. 9M subscribers in the NoStupidQuestions community. ’ ‘You speak of what you do not know, when you liken Moria to the stronghold of Sauron,’ answered Gandalf. On all the others a The name of Moria is black. Open comment sort options . Moria was lost to the Balrog circa 1980 of the Third Age. Balin's expedition began in 2994. The cave troll fighting in a room with a sunbeam is also problematic. Why didn t Gimli know the password to Moria? Why doesn’t Gimli know the password to the Mines of Moria? Again based in the movies (guess I should re-read the books), Gimli was very much advocating that the Fellowship pass through Moria and be guests of his cousin Balin (who was on the quest with Bilbo in "The Hobbit"). So I think OP is right. ” In the books, Gimli and the dwarves of Erebor have gone 25 years without news of Moria: they assume the worst has happened but they don't know what or how. When Gandalf brings up entering Moria: 'The road that I speak of leads to the Mines of Moria,' said Gandalf. Clearly, evil still lived there, as evidenced by Balin's 30 year silence, but he conveniently ignores Why did Gimli not know about Moria? Gimli and the other Dwarves lived in the kingdom of Erebor and, since Erebor was far away from Moria, news would have been slow between the two kingdoms. Riverwalker12 • • Edited . This is all that is needed, not some convoluted mess In the books, at least, the west gate of Moria had not been used for 1,037 to 4,763 years, making it unlikely that the password had been handed down to Gimli. Dalek. How did gimli not know they were defeated. Did Gandalf know Moria was destroyed? In the books, even Gimli did not want to go to Moria and held only the tiniest of hopes that anyone would be alive there anymore, but not even he had known in how bad a shape it had been - only Gandalf has ever been to Moria (and that was swiftly passing through and in the opposite direction than the Fellowship went which was the reasoning why he didn't know about the Then there was silence, and no word has ever come from Moria since. A place to discuss Lord of the Rings, the Hobbit, and any of Tolkien's work! Obviously he did not relish the idea of dying but his knowledge of the Balrog that he did not share indicates that even your choice cause I know whatll happen both ways" he was like "look, all I know is that Moria sucks, we shouldnt go Gimli, son of Gloin, seems to not know much about the the ring or hobbits despite his To follow up, Dain and everyone in Erebor knows that something bad happened in Moria, but not the details. About a thousand years ago, Moria was overrun by orcs and the Balrog. But that was centuries ago and had nothing to do with Balin's expedition. He even succeeded at that, but his Balin, and Óin, his face darkened, saying that he did not know. "Servants of Sauron" does not necessarily mean creatures that are part of his command structure. And those were 150 good years for the Dwarves. Thorin cut off Azog's forearm and the dwarves eventually won, but there were only 12 or 13 survivors from that battle. Khuzdul did not evolve naturally like Middle-earth's other languages. On entering Moria, Gimli was hopeful, but not optimistic, that they'd find Balin's colony alive and well. 11. The Rings could help grow a horde, but couldn't establish one. SataiOtherGuy • Finally, in the books, they did not decide to enter Moria. Q&A. From Wikipedia: In T. ‘We do not know what he expects,’ said Boromir. They were faceless and intimidating. On all the others a dread fell at the mention of that name. Moria in disrepair is treacherous so he had many reasons. Unfinished Tales, Hunt for the Ring: He know nothing, of course, about the action of the doors. This is very clear in the book. They had attempted to climb the mountain, but were driven back by the storm (which was attributed to the wrath of the mountain itself). Now my question here is. I mean 15 years he would know that kazad-dum was reclaimed by goblins right? Contrast this with the Moria orcs: they were monstrous and indistinct from one another. Moria was in state of war where current situation was unknown. Top. He didn't tell the Hobbits what he sensed in Moria so as not to scare them, but he did want them behind him. `I alone of you have ever been in the dungeons of the Dark Lord, and only in his older and lesser dwelling in Dol Guldur. How did Gimli not know that Moria had been taken over by orcs as well as the balrog in Fellowship of the Ring? upvotes Yes. That being said, Zombierasputin sums it up nicely. The movies makes it seem that he suspected it was there, based on the line from Saruman “you know what they awoke in the depths” They don't know the current situation. Obviously Gandalf and Aragorn were right, that Balin’s attempt to restore Moria failed. Business, Economics, and Finance. So, why didn't Gimli know about Moria or what happened to Why did Gimli know about Moria? Gimli was unaware of Moria’s fall until he discovered Balin’s tomb. Not just in Moria but in the entire misty mountain chain. As well, nobody knew that Durin's Bane was a Balrog. Tolkien's The Lord of the Rings. You reasoned that Gimli did not mentioned the battle near the river because it would be depressing for him: He did mention Moria though, and I would like to know how you think that is different. Before entering Moria, it was just known as Durin’s Bane, and no one knew what it truly was. However, in the Hobbit they spoke several times that Moria has been over run and all of the Dwarves know it, even Gimli's faither. Quite the opposite is true. Gimli’s whole mission was about investigating why contact with Moria had been cut off, so he for sure wanted to go there. Compared to the languages of Elves, Men, and Orcs, Khuzdul changed little over time. I think Legolas calls it by name, even. Gimli wanted to go thought Moria while Gandalf was against that idea. GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla. Maybe the original dwarfs of Moria did, but an expedition to retake Moria was lead by Balin, who was a member of Thorin's company roughly 60 years before the event of Fellowship. Basically 15 years isn’t as long for a dwarf as for a human so maybe they just thought Balin was like super busy and couldn’t send a message Moria (it wasn't just mines) was the home of the Longbeard clan of the dwarves, and during the later second and third age, was the most powerful and largest dwelling of the dwarves in Middle Earth. I just searched this up. Gimli (somehow) had no idea Moria was destroyed by the Pale Orc (Azog) several decades ago (hobbit 1). Many events pave the way to the famous scene of Gandalf holding off the Balrog as However, it's strange Gimli wasn't aware of Balin's, and Moria's, grim fate. The fellowship entered the city in 3019. The occupants were long dead. iirc, the debate of whether to go to Moria was between Gandalf and Aragorn, ultimately leaving the decision to Frodo Did Gandalf Know The Mines Of Moria Had Fallen? In The Lord of the Rings, Gimli had no idea the Mines of Moria had fallen, which is why he suggested taking the road through Moria. They had regular communication for 5 years, then it was suddenly cut off with no one hearing anything for 25 years. They died five years before Fellowship, I believe. Why didn't Gimli know any of this? wasn't Gimli's dad part of the company that retook Arebor? Balin died 25 years before the Fellowship arrived in Moria. Why Didn't Gimli Know Moria was Lost? • Gimli's Moria Mystery • Discover why Gimli didn't know Moria was lost, as centuries had passed since Dwarves inhabite Why didn’t Gimli know of the fall of Moria? As someone closely related to the king of Moria, how could he not have known of morias ruin? That question just came to me after rewatching the fellowship. New. Think Aragorn stated in the books that there were crimes going on which is why he didn’t want to go to Moria. TL;DR for the Gimli question: Nobody knew what happened to the dwarves who tried to reclaim Moria, Gimli was probably just being an Moria and Erebor are far away from each other, separated by a great forest and vast, empty plains. Legolas only says "I do not wish to go to Moria. Gandalf seems to know this. There's a big difference between suspecting a loved one was How can middle earth not know that, how can Gandalf not know that dwarves of Moria were wiped out and there is nothing but evil there? Question In the first movie, the fellowship decides to go through mines of Moria and Gimli brags about his cousin Balin and their hospitality, not knowing about the goblins and the balrog. Posts: 3,732 Threads: 2,515 Joined: Apr 2008 #1. They talk about them in The Hobbit when he would take his secret paths to throttle unsuspecting goblins How did Gimli not know of what happened to Why didn’t Gimli know Moria had fallen? Thread Modes. That's one of the reason why Gimli with his father came Imladris. Balin’s expedition went to Moria about 30 years before Gimli and the rest of the Moria was lost to dwarfs for a long long time, when Balin, with his expedition, set on a journey to reclaim it again. We also know that the Moria Orcs who travelled with Uglúk were independent actors. Be the first to comment Nobody's responded to this post yet. I’m not fond of reading books but Dain did not see Durin's Bane. The poor communication between Erebor and Moria, combined with the Dwarves’ extended lifespans, contributed to Gimli’s lack of knowledge about the destruction of Moria. Gandalf suspected that Balin and company were dead, but didn't know for sure. First, see how Gimli does not interrupt the dialogue of Aragorn and Legolas concerning Fangorn. Finding out what happened there is one of the reasons Gimli travels to Rivendell in the first place, because emissaries from Sauron approached Dain Ironfoot with an offer of the remaining Dwarven Rings and ownership of Moria if he joined The Mystery of Moria: Why Gimli Didn't Know the Password • Moria Mystery • Discover why Gimli didn't know the password to Moria and how a riddle, not a simpl [LOTR] How did Gimli not know of the demise of Moria? It is told that the dwarves released the balrog some 900 years before gandalf took the fellowship beneath the mountains. Anárion But I don't know if this fits with his character. Gimli is actually the first Not knowing what really happened, Glóin and his son Gimli were sent to Rivendell to seek news about the colony. Dwarven group settled in Moria but their situation is unknown. It just made Gimli seem dumb, and many people I know who were LOTR fans hated that Gimli just became comic relief in that regard. B. It is thought that at about this time, being hunted both by Elves and Sauron's servants, he took refuge in Moria; but when he had at last discovered the way to the West-gate he could not get out. So sometime in those 77 years, Balin and the Dwarves of Moria were slaughtered. Sort by: Best. Terminal velocity for a free falling human is between 50 and 70 meters per second (depending on a lot of things). He had never been to Moria before. Dain felt the terrifying presence of the monster when he looked into Moria from the East-gate. So him picking up the axe seems to be explicitly a "MOVIE" thing. In conclusion, Gimli’s ignorance about the fall of Moria can be explained by poor communication between Erebor and Moria, the insular nature of the Dwarves, and their extended lifespans. He knew cracks and paths no one else knew. 41). But not until they read parts of the book that they found in the Chamber of Mazarbul did either of them know for certain that Balin's colony had perished, and how. According to one theory (via Stack Exchange), Gimli did not know about the fall of Moria in The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring movie due, effectively, to poor communication. Many people thought setting up a colony to retake Moria was very dangerous, even foolish. I think Tolkien was enough of a philologist that the fact that Legolas expressed only a preference, as Aragorn, not to go, but did not express a future statement - I Gandalf did not know there was a Balrog beneath Moria, though, so his motivation for taking that path was probably more about wanting to engage with Balin’s clan and get their support. In that case to enter Moria would be to walk into a trap, hardly better than knocking at the gates of the Dark Tower itself. For a while we had news and it seemed good: messages reported that Moria had been entered and a great work begun there. ‘Let nothing that dwells in Fangorn be troubled on my account!’ Here, the observations are twofold. How on middle earth did Gimli not know about the Mines of Moria but two wizards halfway across the continent know everything about it including the summoning of a demon fire monster? Did you miss the part where Balin, Ori and Óin, as well as Dwarves called Flói, Lóni, Frár and Náli, among others, reclaimed the eastern portions of Moria including the East Gate, the First to Twenty-First Halls, The Bridge Of Khazad-dûm and the Chamber Of Mazarbul as well as recovering the helm and axe of Durin The Deathless. Gimli also wanted to know what happened to the earlier expedition; he knew it wasn't a success because no one had heard from them in decades. So, why didn't Gimli know about Moria or what happened to his own cousin? Related: Before the Ring, Gollum Was a Unique Type of Hobbit How Did Balin Become Lord of Gimli might be one of those characters who doesn’t get a whole lot of attention, but there is one real moment in The Fellowship of the Ring that tells us a b The fellowship only learns about that from the book they found detailing the attempt to reclaim Moria. Why doesn’t Gimli know what happened in Moria? Aragorn warns that there is danger to Gandalf in particular if they That’s the reason Gimli is even at the council of Elrond, him and the other dwarves are inquiring about Balin and Moria. Than Aragorn and Boromir argue (strongly) against entering it. Why did Gimli not know about Moria? Gimli and the other Dwarves lived in the kingdom of Erebor and, since Erebor was far away from Moria, news would have been slow between the two kingdoms. In the film, this timeline is shifted so we start at the point Gimli was well aware that Moria was rumored to be a dangerous place inhabited by “demons. 2024 Movie Releases; The CW; Dragon Ball; How Come Didn't Gimli Know About the Dwarves' Fate in Moria in How did Gimli not know about Moria? Gimli did know that Moria is a dangerous place, but he didn’t know that his cousin Balin’s expedition has failed so horribly. Travel probably was scarce and for Dwarves, sixty years are not a long time. (Erebor, the Glittering Caves, and Moria once it is re-established) if somebody doesn't spawn some Dwarflings they'll sooner or later have to invent democracy (would be about time) :-P Both Gandalf and Aragorn had previously journeyed through Moria and did not encounter it but for Aragorn the journey was terrifying enough that he would not speak of it, perhaps because he felt the presence of the Balrog. Only Gimli lifted up his head; a smouldering fire was in his eyes. Menu. By the time of LotR that was about a thousand years ago, in the Third Age year 1980. The journey to Moria was dangerous, so many messengers could Kenny Chung (@kennychungk). Crypto Gimli was not against entering Moria. Even if they had passed Redhorn, Gimli would have wanted to pass by Moria. 3. . Gimli was not against entering Moria. This large double bladed greataxe is the iconic AXE that Gimli uses, and it always stood out to me. Score = Gimli: 42 - Legolas: 41 (The movies say 43 - 42 not sure where they got that from. When the Fellowship was considering going through Moria, all that assumed it there would not be any living dwarves in Moria, though they did hope they may encounter them. Everyone else is like "oh shit no not Moria, Moria's fucked" but they realize that it's the only way. True, but all those Dwarves you mention were older than Gimli, and we don't know how many of them married and had kids. Like those who spoke it, Khuzdul was resilient. `We do not know,' he I didn't know what Moria meant before reading this post lol. The dwarves did not posses weapons that could harm it. I can imagine that in all those years it wasn't concerning they had So, Gandalf and Aragorn were pretty sure that going through Moria was going to be a bad idea, but Gimli thought it was going to be a jolly visit to cousin Balin with feasting and comfort. He just had a really bad feeling about going that route and knew they should only take that route if necessary In the books, everyone in the fellowship (including Gimli) knew that Moria was under a dark shadow. How Did Gimli Not Know About Moria? One would think that a disaster like that would be known among the Dwarves, especially considering it was a mission to retake a long-lost Dwarven kingdom. Everyone other than the hobbits knew the history of Moria. In the book, Gandalf and Gimli both suspect that all may not be well in Moria, but that doesn’t make for such a good bait-and-switch in a film: it makes for better viewing to have Gimli eager and excited to see his cousin again, and then be full of sorrow when he discovers the truth. So how exactly does Gimli not know about Moria. Also in the books, and I’d assume in the movies too, the dwarves knew the legends of how Durin’s Bane killed king Then there was silence, and no word has ever come from Moria since. The movies have a much less certain history and chronology, so I don't know how long it had been in the movies since the west gate had been in use. ’ ‘You speak of what you do not know, when you liken Moria to the stronghold of Sauron I honestly believe this was a play on Gandalf being an all-knowing great wizard. 2989 Balin left Gimli didn't know about Moria's fate because there had been no communication between Erebor and Moria for 25 years, and the Dwarves were hopeful and did not want to accept Gimli is pushing Moria, out of a determination to find out what happened to Balin. in front of Gimli. Why didn't Gimli? The short answer is that this only happens in the movies. Alvin Eriol Not knowing what really happened, Glóin and his son Gimli were sent to Rivendell to seek news about the colony. Boromir says he will not. In the section "Of Dwarves and Men" from The Peoples of Middle-earth, Tolkien equated In the book, Gimli's eagerness to go into Moria is not so much because he expects Balin to be there and well, but because he wants to learn what became of him. It was an invention of Aulë, the Vala who created the race of Dwarves. I just don’t get that elves, men, wizards even other dwarves Why did Gimli not know about Moria? Gimli and the other Dwarves lived in the kingdom of Erebor and, since Erebor was far away from Moria, news would have been slow between the two kingdoms. Trending Submenu. Gandalf knew about fall of moria while Gimli no. comments sorted by Best Top New Controversial Q&A Add a Comment. Did he not know that Moria had fallen like a thousand years ago? OP . Gimli won. **It's like Ask Science, but all questions and answers are written with Why Didn't Gimli Know Moria was Lost? • Gimli's Moria Mystery • Discover why Gimli didn't know Moria was lost, as centuries had passed since Dwarves inhabite That is one of the reasons Gloin and Gimli went to Rivendell to confer with Elrond. Now you also know that Galadriel wasn't just saying nice things about Moria to Gimli just because, she was saying those from the bottom of her heart. On a side note, Dain was only 32 at Azunulbizar, while Gimli was 62 at the time of the events in The Hobbit, but was not invited on the Quest for the Lonely Mountain. SataiOtherGuy • 35 votes, 19 comments. They'd be like guys who went off looking for the North West Passage in 1840 and never returned. Gimli was well aware of this. Everyone knows about the orcs, not many people know about the Balrog, it's just some mysterious force that killed the old rulers of Moria. ~The Council of Elrond ‘We do not know what he expects,’ said Boromir. With a new TV show titled Lord of the Rings: Rings The confusing part of that scene for me was always that Gimli seemed to think Moria was going to be filled with feasting and carousing dwarves but instead it was filled with ancient skeletons. The discussion before Moria 'The road that I speak of leads to the Mines of Moria,' said Gandalf. Even to the hobbits it was a legend of vague fear. This theory explains why Gimli, son of Glóin, didn't know anything about Moria's final fate in The Fellowship of the Ring. And none one had heard from Balin in five years about his attempt to retake Moria. While Gimli was aware of the general state of Moria, he did not know the extent of the danger that lay within. ' Gimli did not know what had become of Balin and Co. Surprisingly, it seems Aragorn did not know what a Balrog is. Come on in, have a seat! This subreddit is a warm resting place for all weary travelers who are fond of Gandalf knows about the shadow that has been awoken, as shown in a flashback, but doesn't mention it. However, there is no description of Gimli picking it up, nor of his Battle Cry "There is still one dwarf yet in Moria who still draws breath". Gimli and his people hadn't heard Gimli did know that Moria is a dangerous place, but he didn’t know that his cousin Balin’s expedition has failed so horribly. Best. In our terms, Moria had fallen long ago. isxa gztyev aqy nfjw bbumr gqs dgg dgb sqt nwafv